They've swarmed the streets of New York, spread to cities across America and erupted in fury in European capitals, but the Occupy Wall Street protests popping up around the globe have yet to materialize in Russia.
Complaints of economic inequality could surely find a voice in Moscow, but demonstrations against the haves by the have-nots have yet to pick up steam.
Analysts and politicians contacted by The Moscow Times ascribed the apathy to the weakness of Russian capitalism, and added that the government would crack down on any discontent, nipping serious social protest in the bud.
An Occupy Russia
On Saturday, when simultaneous protests were held in cities around the world — with thousands raucously bringing traffic to a standstill from Santiago, Chile, to Madrid — a small but determined group of perhaps 10 Muscovites joined in near the Bolshoi Theater,
Another photo, carried by Openspace.ru, showed that protesters hung a
Still, the global protests have caught the attention of the country's leadership and have appeared to create a dilemma for Prime Minister Vladimir Putin as he seeks to return to the office of the presidency. He has used the threat of unrest to defend plans to bolster social spending.
"Hundreds of thousands of people — not just a bunch of outcasts but hundreds of thousands — are coming out onto the streets to demand what their governments are unable to fulfill," he said Monday. "If this [social spending] does not take place, then we could get to a situation that we see in countries with developed economies."
Yet so far there has been no sign of "tent cities at bank or stock brokerage headquarters," or "indignant demonstrators near the palaces and villas of government officials and commercial magnates," the respectable liberal web newspaper Gazeta.ru noted in an
Despite the perceived sense that things may not be entirely right in Russia, many observers said conditions were not yet ripe for the types of protests shaking the West to emerge.
"I don't think people here are so angered by the actions of corporate and financial institutions as you are seeing elsewhere," said Duma Deputy Ilya Ponomaryov, of the A Just Russia party. "Capitalism and whatever its ills are not so firmly entrenched here. There is a deeper history and feeling over these issues elsewhere."
"The main concerns here are perhaps more political, rather than directly financial, so the meaning of these protests is maybe not resonating in the same way," he said by telephone Tuesday.
Even if the public outrage existed, it would never be allowed to flourish, said Andrei Piontkovsky, an independent political analyst.
"Putin would never allow it to get started," Piontkovsky said. "He has already said that what is going on in the West would not be good for Russia. I think that is signal enough we won't see it here."
At the same time, state-run television has widely broadcast footage of the protests but has presented them as proof that the United States is a failing and reckless steward of the global economy.
The broadcasts have also tended to focus on the more fringe elements in the crowds to perhaps discourage Russians from following suit.