President Vladimir Putin has never hidden his admiration for Yury Andropov, head of the KGB and his boss when Putin was serving in the Soviet secret police. One of Putin's first public acts after becoming prime minister in 1999 was to reinstate the memorial plaque for Andropov on the Federal Security Service building on Lubyanskaya Ploshchad. At the unveiling, Putin had only warm words for Andropov, calling him "an eminent political figure."
Lyudmila Alexeyeva, a veteran of the human rights movement and head of the Moscow Helsinki Group,
Alexeyeva wrote on her blog on the Ekho Moskvy site, "The Moscow Helsinki Group was founded in 1976. We survived Soviet power. We worked then, and we're working now. And we'll continue to work, no matter what laws are written."
Theoretically, transparency concerning political organizations that receive foreign money is not a bad idea. Analogous legislation exists in democratic countries, most notably the Foreign Agents Registration Act in the United States. But the devil is always in the details. The new Russian bill formulates "political activities" so broadly that it includes almost everything. The legislation defines it as any activity "to influence state decision-making, change state policy or shape public opinion."
Not surprisingly, every human rights organization falls into this definition of "political."
"We don't and can't have any other function than to influence public opinion," Alexeyeva wrote. The only thing we can do is say: 'Dear citizens, if your rights are violated, we can tell you how to defend them.'"
Former Finance Minister Alexei Kudrin
It appears that even the initiators of the bill recognize its absurdity, but it doesn't faze them. An anonymous official in the Kremlin
The legislation has not yet been signed into effect, but there is already a booming business in denunciations of possible "foreign agents." Robert Shlegel, a Duma deputy from United Russia, believes that the Gorbachev Foundation, headed by former Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev, falls into this new category. "Who else but [Gorbachev] fits the description of a foreign agent? I wouldn't be at all surprised to find out he has been working for some foreign special service," he
Shlegel's "exposure" of Gorbachev confirms the warnings of opposition leader Boris Nemtsov, who
But some people see a positive side of the bill. Alexei Kalinov, a Moscow businessman,
Unfortunately, Russian history has shown that optimism is never a good tool when making predictions. It's difficult to say how many NGOs will be able to continue their work if the new legislation is put into effect. In any case, it will close the door on fundraising in Russia, since no Russian donor would dare to fund "foreign agents."
Alexeyeva wrote on her Ekho Moskvy blog: "On the day I learned that the bill had been submitted [to the Duma], I asked Mikhail Fedotov, an aide to the president, to pass on my official statement to Vladimir Putin. Under no circumstances will the Moscow Helsinki Group register as an agent of a foreign state because we are not agents."
This statement might be very risky. In his time, Andropov succeeded in dissolving the first Moscow Helsinki Group. Putin might very well enjoy doing it again out of deep respect for Andropov.