Service Gets Tough On Spelling Errors
18 June 2009
By Alexei Nikolsky and Dmitry Kazmin / Vedomosti
The Federal Anti-Monopoly Service has annulled contracts worth 1.2 billion rubles ($38.5 million) for state orders because of typographical distortions in six declarations, and more than 2,000 other violations have been found and will be investigated.
Using Latin letters instead of Cyrillic, as well as other typographical tricks, could be used to short-circuit the competitive bidding process. Using nonstandard spellings in declarations on the government's web site for state purchase could allow well-connected firms to land sweetheart deals if other companies are unable to find the order.
Vatutinki, a children's welfare center, left out the space between the words "children" and "Vatutinki" in its announcement on the web site Zakupki.gov.ru about buying reconstruction work worth 106.2 million rubles.
All government bodies ordering goods or services are required to post announcements on the site about the start of bidding, the terms of the tender and the rules for evaluating bids. Bidding on the Vatutinki order is set for July 9.
According to Economic Development Ministry figures, the federal government will spend 1.35 trillion rubles ($43 billion) on goods, work and other services this year, excluding classified military orders, and the figure will exceed 4 trillion rubles when combined with regional and municipal orders.
The bidding on an order posted by Shchyolkovsky Biokombinat -- for the production and oversight of a culture of inactive anti-rabies vaccine valued at 773 million rubles -- was held March 11, and it was won by PSK Union-Stroi, the only firm to bid. In the announcement's key words, the Cyrillic letter "k" was replaced with the Latin one, and the letter "o" was replaced with the number "0."
Tricks involving the substitution of letters is hardly new, dating at least back to 2006, when the new law on state orders came into effect, said Alexander Stroganov, general director of the State Orders Placement Center. Such methods lead to significantly fewer bids, said Alexei Morozov, one of the authors of the National Rating of Purchasing Transparency. The bidding in such cases involves one or two suppliers, and the price is 10 percent to 15 percent higher than in competitive tenders, he said.
On Tuesday, the anti-monopoly service official announced that distorted spellings in the announcements would lead to the nullification of orders. "The aforementioned actions of the buyers essentially mean that bidding is not being held, since potential participants in the tender cannot find information about it by keywords on the official site," the service said.
The service attached to the announcement a list of six violations for a total sum of more than 1.2 billion rubles. On Wednesday, another 16 tenders were to be investigated, said Mikhail Yevrayev, the service's managing director. In total, some 2,000 purchases with distorted listings will be investigated, he said.
Yevrayev said that in the cases where a contract has not yet been signed, the anti-monopoly service would void the offers for violating the rules for announcing a purchase (Article 16 of the Law on State Orders). In instances where a contract was signed, the service will seek to have it annulled in court.
Citing Article 16 does not make sense, said an official at one of the bodies accused of distorting listings: the announcements were published in time, and while the search engine on the official site did not work because of the mistakes, Yandex found them. "We're not going to go to court, but some of the other victims are planning to," he said.
Those who are keeping track of the orders will find out about the announcements, even if there are mistakes, agreed Union-Stroi director Vladimir Mikhnovich. The tricks with typos, he said, come from the buyer's desire to find a reliable person to do the work.
"Otherwise, companies you've never heard of will come, win and then won't do the work because they aren't able."
The heads of the Shchyolkovsky Biokombinat and Vatutinki did not answer their phones Tuesday.
If the orders were related to defense, such as the Shchyolkovsky Biokombinat offer, the information will be handed over to the Federal Service for Defense Contracts, which should take similar steps, Yevrayev said.
A Defense Ministry source said the defense contracts service was looking over the anti-monopoly service's materials, and if it finds violations in any of the tenders it could go to court to nullify the contract. If financing of the program already began, however, the situation will be much more complicated, he said.
"It's possible to halt the completion of an order through the courts, but in most cases, the completion of such an order will most likely have to be entrusted to the organization that began it," the Defense Ministry source said.
The matter will not be limited to technical repercussions, Yevrayev said. Those responsible for the faulty announcements will face 50,000 ruble ($1,600) administrative fines. Additionally, the heads of agencies overseeing the bodies making the orders will be sent letters requesting a review of whether the managers are fit to hold their posts.
In all of the cases, the documents will also be handed over to the Prosecutor General's Office and the Interior Ministry, Yevrayev added.
The Federal Anti-Monopoly Service will need to separate the intentional distortions from the careless mistakes, warned Stroganov, and in court it will be difficult to prove the intent of such mistakes.
"It's nearly impossible," said a source in the Interior Ministry. Without that, it is impossible to open a case of limiting competition (Article 178 of the Criminal Code, punishable by up to five years in prison).
A spokesperson for the Agriculture Ministry, which oversees the Shchyolkovsky Biokombinat, said the ministry had not yet seen any documents from the anti-monopoly service.
Using Latin letters instead of Cyrillic, as well as other typographical tricks, could be used to short-circuit the competitive bidding process. Using nonstandard spellings in declarations on the government's web site for state purchase could allow well-connected firms to land sweetheart deals if other companies are unable to find the order.
Vatutinki, a children's welfare center, left out the space between the words "children" and "Vatutinki" in its announcement on the web site Zakupki.gov.ru about buying reconstruction work worth 106.2 million rubles.
All government bodies ordering goods or services are required to post announcements on the site about the start of bidding, the terms of the tender and the rules for evaluating bids. Bidding on the Vatutinki order is set for July 9.
According to Economic Development Ministry figures, the federal government will spend 1.35 trillion rubles ($43 billion) on goods, work and other services this year, excluding classified military orders, and the figure will exceed 4 trillion rubles when combined with regional and municipal orders.
The bidding on an order posted by Shchyolkovsky Biokombinat -- for the production and oversight of a culture of inactive anti-rabies vaccine valued at 773 million rubles -- was held March 11, and it was won by PSK Union-Stroi, the only firm to bid. In the announcement's key words, the Cyrillic letter "k" was replaced with the Latin one, and the letter "o" was replaced with the number "0."
Tricks involving the substitution of letters is hardly new, dating at least back to 2006, when the new law on state orders came into effect, said Alexander Stroganov, general director of the State Orders Placement Center. Such methods lead to significantly fewer bids, said Alexei Morozov, one of the authors of the National Rating of Purchasing Transparency. The bidding in such cases involves one or two suppliers, and the price is 10 percent to 15 percent higher than in competitive tenders, he said.
On Tuesday, the anti-monopoly service official announced that distorted spellings in the announcements would lead to the nullification of orders. "The aforementioned actions of the buyers essentially mean that bidding is not being held, since potential participants in the tender cannot find information about it by keywords on the official site," the service said.
The service attached to the announcement a list of six violations for a total sum of more than 1.2 billion rubles. On Wednesday, another 16 tenders were to be investigated, said Mikhail Yevrayev, the service's managing director. In total, some 2,000 purchases with distorted listings will be investigated, he said.
Yevrayev said that in the cases where a contract has not yet been signed, the anti-monopoly service would void the offers for violating the rules for announcing a purchase (Article 16 of the Law on State Orders). In instances where a contract was signed, the service will seek to have it annulled in court.
Citing Article 16 does not make sense, said an official at one of the bodies accused of distorting listings: the announcements were published in time, and while the search engine on the official site did not work because of the mistakes, Yandex found them. "We're not going to go to court, but some of the other victims are planning to," he said.
Those who are keeping track of the orders will find out about the announcements, even if there are mistakes, agreed Union-Stroi director Vladimir Mikhnovich. The tricks with typos, he said, come from the buyer's desire to find a reliable person to do the work.
"Otherwise, companies you've never heard of will come, win and then won't do the work because they aren't able."
The heads of the Shchyolkovsky Biokombinat and Vatutinki did not answer their phones Tuesday.
If the orders were related to defense, such as the Shchyolkovsky Biokombinat offer, the information will be handed over to the Federal Service for Defense Contracts, which should take similar steps, Yevrayev said.
A Defense Ministry source said the defense contracts service was looking over the anti-monopoly service's materials, and if it finds violations in any of the tenders it could go to court to nullify the contract. If financing of the program already began, however, the situation will be much more complicated, he said.
"It's possible to halt the completion of an order through the courts, but in most cases, the completion of such an order will most likely have to be entrusted to the organization that began it," the Defense Ministry source said.
The matter will not be limited to technical repercussions, Yevrayev said. Those responsible for the faulty announcements will face 50,000 ruble ($1,600) administrative fines. Additionally, the heads of agencies overseeing the bodies making the orders will be sent letters requesting a review of whether the managers are fit to hold their posts.
In all of the cases, the documents will also be handed over to the Prosecutor General's Office and the Interior Ministry, Yevrayev added.
The Federal Anti-Monopoly Service will need to separate the intentional distortions from the careless mistakes, warned Stroganov, and in court it will be difficult to prove the intent of such mistakes.
"It's nearly impossible," said a source in the Interior Ministry. Without that, it is impossible to open a case of limiting competition (Article 178 of the Criminal Code, punishable by up to five years in prison).
A spokesperson for the Agriculture Ministry, which oversees the Shchyolkovsky Biokombinat, said the ministry had not yet seen any documents from the anti-monopoly service.
Discussion
Comments
To post comments you must be registered
Comments via Facebook
Most Read
1.
Journalist Booted After Visa Violation
A prominent French writer and journalist has been kicked out of the country on the grounds that she did not have the right to research a book while on a business visa.
2.
Putin Plan Targets Population Drop
Prime Minister Vladimir Putin unveiled his plan on social policy Monday, focusing on how Russia will boost its dwindling population amid a demographic crisis that threatens to turn the country into "void space."
3.
Putin's Campaign Manager Calls Liberals "Filth of the Nation"
Vladimir Putin's campaign manager Stanislav Govorukhin quoted Soviet leader Vladimir Lenin in calling the liberal intelligentsia "the filth of the nation" in an interview published Monday.
4.
Air Force Touts Latest Acquisitions
The fifth-generation PAK FA T-50 jet fighter will have a higher maximum speed, longer maximum flight time and greater freight capacity than the American-made F-22 and the Chinese J-20.
5.
Start of Stadium Demolition Draws Outcry
Architectural preservation group Arkhnadzor said Monday that demolition at the constructivist-era Dynamo football stadium as a part of ongoing building work was against the law.
6.
Irina Prokhorova to Stand in for Brother in Debate With Putin Proxy Nikita Mikhalkov
Irina Prokhorova, editor of the journal New Literary Review and sister of businessman and presidential candidate Mikhail Prokhorov will represent her brother in a televised debate with Nikita Mikhalkov, film director and backer of presidential candidate Vladimir Putin.
7.
Officer on Atomic Submarine Commits Suicide
A senior lieutenant serving on the Gepard atomic submarine, part of the Northern Fleet, hanged himself in his cabin.
8.
We Want Reforms, Not Revolution
The main lesson from the rival anti-Putin and pro-Putin demonstrations held on Feb. 4 is that both civil society and the authorities are walking down a dangerous path of escalation.
9.
Poland Uses Shale Gas to Shake Reliance on Russia
When Wieslaw Radzieciak took office as the mayor of Lesniowice in the gently rolling farmland of southeastern Poland 26 years ago, the Soviet garrisons that dotted the region were a stark reminder of which superpower was in control.
10.
Navalny Nominated For Aeroflot Board
Anti-corruption blogger and opposition leader Alexei Navalny could become a member of the board of Aeroflot after he was nominated to the position by billionaire Alexander Lebedev.
1.
Putin Stand-In Faces Zhirinovsky Fire
In Tuesday's second presidential debate of the campaign season, firebrand Vladimir Zhirinovsky harangued Prime Minister Vladimir Putin's levelheaded proxy over her patron's refusal to debate and alleged desire to rule for life.
2.
Pro-Putin Song Is Web Hit
A schmaltzy music video hailing Prime Minister Vladimir Putin as Russia's savior became a hit on the Russian Internet on Tuesday, with many bloggers and YouTube users poking fun at the song's hyperbolic lyrics.
3.
Lavrov in Syria to Strongly Back Assad
Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov met with Syrian President Bashar Assad in Damascus on Tuesday, sending a clear message that Russia intends to stand by its strongest ally in the Middle East amid an international outcry over the country's response to a civil revolt.
4.
Putin Chasing Imaginary American Ghosts
Here we go again — another round of anti-Americanism from the Kremlin and state-controlled media. Blaming outside forces for Russia's woes has a long history in the country. The closer we get to the March 4 presidential election, the more intense the anti-American hysteria becomes.
5.
Campaign Mudslinging Taken to New Lows
If politics is a dirty business, then Russia is no exception.
6.
Moscow Is Unlovable and Unlivable
Today's Moscow is unlovable and unlivable, overdeveloped, underserved by public utilities and choked by traffic. You can't drive, you can't breathe, there is no place to park and walking is impossible thanks to giant SUVs lining the sidewalks.
7.
FSB Upgrades from iPads to Pricey Typewriters
The Federal Security Service paid over 2 million rubles ($67,000) for an order of nearly 100 typewriters, or about 22,000 rubles per machine.
8.
Report: United Russia Might Be Dismantled
United Russia, the country's dominant political party for more than a decade, might be radically reformed or even dissolved in the coming months.
9.
Realpolitik Without Realism
People have been asking me all week why the Kremlin is so stubbornly supportive of Syrian President Bashar Assad. "Is Russia's support based solely on weapons contracts with Syria," they wonder, "or the Kremlin's desire to maintain its naval base at the Tartus port?"
10.
Journalist Booted After Visa Violation
A prominent French writer and journalist has been kicked out of the country on the grounds that she did not have the right to research a book while on a business visa.
1.
Election Webcam Installation Begins
In a city that was once the cradle of Russian democracy, an unprecedented new campaign kicked off over the weekend to install web cameras in every polling station around the country in an effort to prevent voting fraud.
2.
Feminist Punk Band Become Unlikely Putin Foil
Pussy Riot, a feminist punk collective from Moscow, creates protest through its dissident songs and unsanctioned performances, including a brief unauthorized concert in late January on Red Square.
3.
Why Putin Will Never, Ever Give Up Power
If Putin gave up power at any age, he and dozens of his friends and colleagues who have become millionaires and billionaires over the past 10 years through their Kremlin-connected businesses could face serious corruption charges. This is why the best, and perhaps only, way for Putin to preserve immunity is to stay in power until death.
4.
Why Putin Is Mad at Me
Prime Minister Vladimir Putin got very angry last Wednesday when he met with the editors-in-chief of Russia's top media outlets.
5.
Russia Seeks Proof U.S. Zapped Failed Probe
A Russian state commission investigating the crash of the Fobos-Grunt Mars probe will conduct tests to see whether U.S. radar played a role in the spacecraft's failure.
6.
Putin Stand-In Faces Zhirinovsky Fire
In Tuesday's second presidential debate of the campaign season, firebrand Vladimir Zhirinovsky harangued Prime Minister Vladimir Putin's levelheaded proxy over her patron's refusal to debate and alleged desire to rule for life.
7.
Recruiters Say Mother Russia Seeking Talent
Demographics make it a candidate’s market, but foreigners have to offer something unique to find their place.
8.
Pro-Putin Song Is Web Hit
A schmaltzy music video hailing Prime Minister Vladimir Putin as Russia's savior became a hit on the Russian Internet on Tuesday, with many bloggers and YouTube users poking fun at the song's hyperbolic lyrics.
9.
From Protest to Nausea
The history of successive authoritarian regimes in Russia reveals a recurring pattern: They do not die from external blows or domestic insurgencies.
10.
Why Putin Is So Scared of Debates
Putin has always been the ultimate "Teflon president" — but certainly not in the Ronald Reagan sense of the word. Putin's brand of Teflon is clearly made in Russia. Because he wants to avoid uncomfortable questions about his decade-long rule, Putin is once again refusing to participate in presidential debates.


