Russia Sidelined in U.S. Campaign
28 January 2008
By Miriam Elder
NEW YORK -- With the U.S. economic downturn, the war in Iraq and the threat of looming conflict with Iran, it is little wonder that candidates in the heated U.S. presidential primaries spare few words for Russia.
While the leading candidates differ on how to deal with a resurgent Russia, they all take a much harder line on the country than the administration of U.S. President George W. Bush.
Yet only two of them -- Republican hopeful John McCain and Democratic contender Hillary Clinton -- have mentioned Russia while addressing an electorate that cares more about the sinking stock market and forging a coherent policy in Iraq. And their remarks have not always been strong on nuance.
"I looked into Putin's eyes and I saw three letters -- a K, a G and a B," McCain said in a December interview with The Boston Herald. Upon first meeting Putin, Bush said he stared into the Russian leader's eyes and "got a sense of his soul."
Addressing voters in Iowa in February 2007, McCain referred to Putin as "President Putin of Germany."
"I was in a conference in Germany over the weekend, and President Putin of Germany gave one of the old Cold War-style speeches," McCain said in the speech, a video of which is posted on YouTube.
The Arizona senator has long been one of the most critical voices on Russia, repeatedly calling for the country's ouster from the Group of Eight over human rights concerns.
McCain renewed that call in a recent opinion piece in The Financial Times, writing: "[W]e in the West must pursue cooperation with Moscow where we can. But too many believe that we can define an agenda of cooperation that is divorced from the nature of the Russian regime and its actions against its own citizens."
McCain, like his three main Republican competitors, supports Bush's plans to deploy elements of a missile defense system in the Czech Republic and Poland.
"If I'm in the Kremlin, he's not my No. 1 candidate," Andrew Kuchins, head of the Russia program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, said of McCain.
McCain is joined in the Republican race by former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney, former Arkansas governor Mike Huckabee, and former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani.
Romney, whose foreign policy team is being led by longtime diplomat Mitchell Reiss, an expert on nuclear issues and North Korea, also supports plans for missile defense and is critical of events inside Russia. But he has urged greater U.S.-Russian cooperation, particularly on nuclear issues.
In a January article in Foreign Affairs, Huckabee said he was pessimistic on Russia's role in resolving the standoff with Iran and described Putin as "a staunch nationalist in a country with no democratic tradition."
"He will do everything he can to reassert Russia's power -- militarily, economically, diplomatically," Huckabee wrote.
None of the candidates have spoken out on Russia's March 2 presidential election, in which Putin's preferred successor, First Deputy Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev, is expected to win in a landslide.
Angela Stent, director of Georgetown University's Center for Eurasian, Russian and East European Studies, said she doubted McCain would follow through on plans to isolate Russia as harshly as he has claimed.
"Usually campaign rhetoric is much stronger than policies that are enacted when they actually become president," Stent said.
Clinton's public remarks on Russia have been comparably harsh, if rhetorical, saying Putin "doesn't have a soul" because he was a KGB agent.
Clinton further criticized Putin in a December article in Foreign Affairs, saying he "suppressed many of the freedoms won after the fall of communism, created a new class of oligarchs, and interfered deeply in the internal affairs of former Soviet republics."
At the same time, she wrote, "we need to engage Russia selectively on issues of high national importance," such as Iran, nuclear weapons and Kosovo.
"There's considerable consensus about the new elements in the [U.S.-Russian] relationship -- the increased points of friction, the unsettling anti-Americanism of political rhetoric, the authoritarian drift of domestic politics," said Stephen Sestanovich, chief Russia expert at the Council on Foreign Relations and Clinton's top advisor on Russia.
"Alongside these new problems is continuing interest in cooperation -- and no one is quite sure how to put the pieces of the strategy together," Sestanovich said.
A Clinton presidency could bode ill for U.S.-Russian relations over Kosovo however. Clinton is believed to have tapped Richard Holbrooke, a former U.S. ambassador to the United Nations and staunch supporter of Kosovo's independence following a long stint as envoy to the Balkans, as her potential secretary of state.
Clinton's main competitor, Illinois Senator Barack Obama, holds a similar stance on Russia, while pushing harder in policy papers for greater cooperation on reducing nuclear stockpiles and boosting democracy inside the country. Michael McFaul, a Russia expert and political science professor at Stanford, is leading Obama's Russia team.
Candidates' policies on Russia could become even clearer when the U.S. Congress begins hearings on Russia's accession to the World Trade Organization later this year, the Kuchins said this year.
Both Kuchins and McFaul joined a chorus of U.S. analysts bemoaning the lack of public discussion on Russia.
"The relationship is at the worst it's been in two decades," McFaul said. "Time and attention have faded gradually. Russia's been downgraded substantially during the Bush years."
In the general election -- especially if the Republican candidate is McCain -- there will be a much more substantial debate over foreign policy, McFaul said.
"Everyone hopes that the political transition in both Russia and the U.S. can be an opportunity to turn the page and to put relations on a more positive footing," Sestanovich said. "But there's no single gimmick that's going to make this happen."
The candidates are still due to battle it out in Florida ahead of "Super Tuesday" on Feb. 5, when 20 states will hold their primaries. Obama won Saturday's Democratic primary in South Carolina, while Clinton finished second.
The Republicans nominate their presidential candidate at a national convention in September, while the Democratic candidate will be determined in late August.
"There are certain parts of the country that care more -- Ohio, Illinois, Michigan -- where there are lots of ethnic Ukrainians and Poles, and these are traditionally swing voters," McFaul said. "For a small percentage of people, a policy on Russia is going to matter."
While the leading candidates differ on how to deal with a resurgent Russia, they all take a much harder line on the country than the administration of U.S. President George W. Bush.
Yet only two of them -- Republican hopeful John McCain and Democratic contender Hillary Clinton -- have mentioned Russia while addressing an electorate that cares more about the sinking stock market and forging a coherent policy in Iraq. And their remarks have not always been strong on nuance.
"I looked into Putin's eyes and I saw three letters -- a K, a G and a B," McCain said in a December interview with The Boston Herald. Upon first meeting Putin, Bush said he stared into the Russian leader's eyes and "got a sense of his soul."
Addressing voters in Iowa in February 2007, McCain referred to Putin as "President Putin of Germany."
"I was in a conference in Germany over the weekend, and President Putin of Germany gave one of the old Cold War-style speeches," McCain said in the speech, a video of which is posted on YouTube.
The Arizona senator has long been one of the most critical voices on Russia, repeatedly calling for the country's ouster from the Group of Eight over human rights concerns.
McCain renewed that call in a recent opinion piece in The Financial Times, writing: "[W]e in the West must pursue cooperation with Moscow where we can. But too many believe that we can define an agenda of cooperation that is divorced from the nature of the Russian regime and its actions against its own citizens."
McCain, like his three main Republican competitors, supports Bush's plans to deploy elements of a missile defense system in the Czech Republic and Poland.
"If I'm in the Kremlin, he's not my No. 1 candidate," Andrew Kuchins, head of the Russia program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, said of McCain.
McCain is joined in the Republican race by former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney, former Arkansas governor Mike Huckabee, and former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani.
Romney, whose foreign policy team is being led by longtime diplomat Mitchell Reiss, an expert on nuclear issues and North Korea, also supports plans for missile defense and is critical of events inside Russia. But he has urged greater U.S.-Russian cooperation, particularly on nuclear issues.
In a January article in Foreign Affairs, Huckabee said he was pessimistic on Russia's role in resolving the standoff with Iran and described Putin as "a staunch nationalist in a country with no democratic tradition."
"He will do everything he can to reassert Russia's power -- militarily, economically, diplomatically," Huckabee wrote.
None of the candidates have spoken out on Russia's March 2 presidential election, in which Putin's preferred successor, First Deputy Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev, is expected to win in a landslide.
Angela Stent, director of Georgetown University's Center for Eurasian, Russian and East European Studies, said she doubted McCain would follow through on plans to isolate Russia as harshly as he has claimed.
"Usually campaign rhetoric is much stronger than policies that are enacted when they actually become president," Stent said.
Clinton's public remarks on Russia have been comparably harsh, if rhetorical, saying Putin "doesn't have a soul" because he was a KGB agent.
Clinton further criticized Putin in a December article in Foreign Affairs, saying he "suppressed many of the freedoms won after the fall of communism, created a new class of oligarchs, and interfered deeply in the internal affairs of former Soviet republics."
At the same time, she wrote, "we need to engage Russia selectively on issues of high national importance," such as Iran, nuclear weapons and Kosovo.
"There's considerable consensus about the new elements in the [U.S.-Russian] relationship -- the increased points of friction, the unsettling anti-Americanism of political rhetoric, the authoritarian drift of domestic politics," said Stephen Sestanovich, chief Russia expert at the Council on Foreign Relations and Clinton's top advisor on Russia.
"Alongside these new problems is continuing interest in cooperation -- and no one is quite sure how to put the pieces of the strategy together," Sestanovich said.
A Clinton presidency could bode ill for U.S.-Russian relations over Kosovo however. Clinton is believed to have tapped Richard Holbrooke, a former U.S. ambassador to the United Nations and staunch supporter of Kosovo's independence following a long stint as envoy to the Balkans, as her potential secretary of state.
Clinton's main competitor, Illinois Senator Barack Obama, holds a similar stance on Russia, while pushing harder in policy papers for greater cooperation on reducing nuclear stockpiles and boosting democracy inside the country. Michael McFaul, a Russia expert and political science professor at Stanford, is leading Obama's Russia team.
Candidates' policies on Russia could become even clearer when the U.S. Congress begins hearings on Russia's accession to the World Trade Organization later this year, the Kuchins said this year.
Both Kuchins and McFaul joined a chorus of U.S. analysts bemoaning the lack of public discussion on Russia.
"The relationship is at the worst it's been in two decades," McFaul said. "Time and attention have faded gradually. Russia's been downgraded substantially during the Bush years."
In the general election -- especially if the Republican candidate is McCain -- there will be a much more substantial debate over foreign policy, McFaul said.
"Everyone hopes that the political transition in both Russia and the U.S. can be an opportunity to turn the page and to put relations on a more positive footing," Sestanovich said. "But there's no single gimmick that's going to make this happen."
The candidates are still due to battle it out in Florida ahead of "Super Tuesday" on Feb. 5, when 20 states will hold their primaries. Obama won Saturday's Democratic primary in South Carolina, while Clinton finished second.
The Republicans nominate their presidential candidate at a national convention in September, while the Democratic candidate will be determined in late August.
"There are certain parts of the country that care more -- Ohio, Illinois, Michigan -- where there are lots of ethnic Ukrainians and Poles, and these are traditionally swing voters," McFaul said. "For a small percentage of people, a policy on Russia is going to matter."
Discussion
Comments
To post comments you must be registered
Comments via Facebook
Most Read
1.
Report: United Russia Might Be Dismantled
United Russia, the country's dominant political party for more than a decade, might be radically reformed or even dissolved in the coming months.
2.
Moscow Is Unlovable and Unlivable
Today's Moscow is unlovable and unlivable, overdeveloped, underserved by public utilities and choked by traffic. You can't drive, you can't breathe, there is no place to park and walking is impossible thanks to giant SUVs lining the sidewalks.
3.
Putin Aide: Corruption Was 'Civilized'
Corruption in Russia was "normal" and "civilized" during Vladimir Putin's first stint as president and support for him has grown stronger as a result of recent opposition rallies, the prime minister's campaign manager has boasted.
4.
Kremlin's Youth Agency Resembles Cosa Nostra
In the Internet age, the famous aphorism of the 19th-century military theorist Karl von Clausewitz, "War is the continuation of policy by other means," may no longer be applicable.
5.
Houston's Death Felt In Russia
Russians joined the world Sunday in mourning the death of singer and actress Whitney Houston, who passed away suddenly at the age of 48.
6.
Woman Ignites Herself
A 56-year-old woman from the Urals set herself on fire in front of the White House on Sunday, two weeks after Prime Minister Vladimir Putin visited her region for a rally supporting his presidential bid.
7.
Venerable Oil Fields Require Ingenuity
The engineer leaned back knee-deep in snow, straining against the taut elastic and released the unmanned drone into the western Siberian sky.
8.
Police Chief Sacked In Reform Shake-Up
The head of the St. Petersburg police was sacked following an investigation into the beating death of a 15-year-old boy while in custody, amid an ugly power struggle that came to head at the annual meeting of police brass with President Dmitry Medvedev.
9.
Protesters Should Copy U.S. Civil Rights March
As Vladimir Putin cruises to an assured presidential victory, Russia's resilient protest movement has to demonstrate that it has the strategy to convert street energy into meaningful political change beyond March 4.
10.
Ryabkov: It's the West's Fault
Russia said Friday that the West is stoking the conflict in Syria by sending weapons to opponents of President Bashar Assad.
1.
Putin Stand-In Faces Zhirinovsky Fire
In Tuesday's second presidential debate of the campaign season, firebrand Vladimir Zhirinovsky harangued Prime Minister Vladimir Putin's levelheaded proxy over her patron's refusal to debate and alleged desire to rule for life.
2.
Pro-Putin Song Is Web Hit
A schmaltzy music video hailing Prime Minister Vladimir Putin as Russia's savior became a hit on the Russian Internet on Tuesday, with many bloggers and YouTube users poking fun at the song's hyperbolic lyrics.
3.
Lavrov in Syria to Strongly Back Assad
Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov met with Syrian President Bashar Assad in Damascus on Tuesday, sending a clear message that Russia intends to stand by its strongest ally in the Middle East amid an international outcry over the country's response to a civil revolt.
4.
Putin Chasing Imaginary American Ghosts
Here we go again — another round of anti-Americanism from the Kremlin and state-controlled media. Blaming outside forces for Russia's woes has a long history in the country. The closer we get to the March 4 presidential election, the more intense the anti-American hysteria becomes.
5.
Malev Goes Bankrupt Owing $130M to VEB
Hungary's state airline Malev stopped flying after 66 years on Friday, citing bankruptcy, amid debts to creditors that include 100 million euros ($130 million) owed to VEB.
6.
McCain Taunts Putin Over Protests
U.S. Senator John McCain has again angered supporters of Prime Minister Vladimir Putin by describing Russia's nascent protest movement as an extension of the Arab Spring uprisings that have shaken and toppled governments across the Middle East.
7.
Campaign Mudslinging Taken to New Lows
If politics is a dirty business, then Russia is no exception.
8.
FSB Upgrades from iPads to Pricey Typewriters
The Federal Security Service paid over 2 million rubles ($67,000) for an order of nearly 100 typewriters, or about 22,000 rubles per machine.
9.
Realpolitik Without Realism
People have been asking me all week why the Kremlin is so stubbornly supportive of Syrian President Bashar Assad. "Is Russia's support based solely on weapons contracts with Syria," they wonder, "or the Kremlin's desire to maintain its naval base at the Tartus port?"
10.
The Truth About Gary Powers, a Cold War Hero
Friday marks the 50th anniversary of the famous spy exchange between U-2 pilot Francis Gary Powers and Soviet spy Rudolph Able on the Glienicker Bridge in Potsdam, Germany.
1.
Election Webcam Installation Begins
In a city that was once the cradle of Russian democracy, an unprecedented new campaign kicked off over the weekend to install web cameras in every polling station around the country in an effort to prevent voting fraud.
2.
Feminist Punk Band Become Unlikely Putin Foil
Pussy Riot, a feminist punk collective from Moscow, creates protest through its dissident songs and unsanctioned performances, including a brief unauthorized concert in late January on Red Square.
3.
Why Putin Will Never, Ever Give Up Power
If Putin gave up power at any age, he and dozens of his friends and colleagues who have become millionaires and billionaires over the past 10 years through their Kremlin-connected businesses could face serious corruption charges. This is why the best, and perhaps only, way for Putin to preserve immunity is to stay in power until death.
4.
Why Putin Is Mad at Me
Prime Minister Vladimir Putin got very angry last Wednesday when he met with the editors-in-chief of Russia's top media outlets.
5.
Russia Seeks Proof U.S. Zapped Failed Probe
A Russian state commission investigating the crash of the Fobos-Grunt Mars probe will conduct tests to see whether U.S. radar played a role in the spacecraft's failure.
6.
Recruiters Say Mother Russia Seeking Talent
Demographics make it a candidate’s market, but foreigners have to offer something unique to find their place.
7.
Putin Stand-In Faces Zhirinovsky Fire
In Tuesday's second presidential debate of the campaign season, firebrand Vladimir Zhirinovsky harangued Prime Minister Vladimir Putin's levelheaded proxy over her patron's refusal to debate and alleged desire to rule for life.
8.
From Protest to Nausea
The history of successive authoritarian regimes in Russia reveals a recurring pattern: They do not die from external blows or domestic insurgencies.
9.
U.K. Spy Rock Confirmation May Boost Putin
A former British official has acknowledged that London spied on Moscow with a fake rock that contained electronic equipment, confirming Russian intelligence claims from 2006 that were mocked but gave Vladimir Putin justification to crack down on nongovernmental organizations.
10.
Why Putin Is So Scared of Debates
Putin has always been the ultimate "Teflon president" — but certainly not in the Ronald Reagan sense of the word. Putin's brand of Teflon is clearly made in Russia. Because he wants to avoid uncomfortable questions about his decade-long rule, Putin is once again refusing to participate in presidential debates.


