Install

Get the latest updates as we post them — right on your browser

Today's paper. Last Updated: 02/04/2012

Retailer Detained In Fraud Probe

Workers standing in Sunrise’s largest store, which was ordered closed last week as part of a fraud investigation.
Vladimir Filonov / MT

Workers standing in Sunrise’s largest store, which was ordered closed last week as part of a fraud investigation.

A court on Tuesday extended the detention of Sunrise owner Sergei Bobylev, whose computer and appliance retailer ran what it called Europe’s largest hardware store, in a major fraud investigation that arose after a dispute with the company’s creditors.

Bobylev’s case is the latest in a string of recent crackdowns on the owners of major retail chains, including Yevroset and Arbat Prestige.

Investigators accuse Bobylev of siphoning assets from the debt-ridden Sunrise to other firms. An investigation was opened in February after complaints were filed by several Sunrise creditors.

If convicted, Bobylev faces up to 10 years in prison.

Nelli Dmitriyeva, the police investigator leading the case, requested that Bobylev come in for questioning at the Main Investigative Directorate of the Moscow police on Monday, and he was subsequently detained.

Police decided to seek Bobylev’s arrest because he had actively resisted the investigation by destroying evidence and threatening witnesses, a police spokeswoman said Tuesday.

Moscow’s Tverskoi District Court postponed a ruling on the arrest until Friday but agreed to extend his detention. Prosecutors and defense lawyers declined requests for comment.

A spokesman for Sunrise, Alexei Baklanov, told The Moscow Times that the case against Bobylev was fabricated to evict the company from the spacious premises it rents in central Moscow.

“We tie all our problems to the actions of Mikhail Dvornikov, a former owner of Savyolovsky [electronics retail] market,” he said. “We rent space for our biggest store at the Stankolit site from his mother, Emma Dvornikova, and his people are trying to throw us out.”

Baklanov said Sunrise has spent $15 million on new pavilions and infrastructure at Stankolit, a vast store at the market, north of Savyolovsky Station. He said Sunrise’s business partners would complain to the presidential administration, the Investigative Committee and the Federal Security Service about the legality of Bobylev’s detention.

“He is a great business strategist, and without him our company will have to go through really hard times,” Baklanov said.

Established in 1992, Sunrise has expanded to about 100 stores in more than 40 Russian cities. The company says on its web site that its Stankolit store is the biggest computer hardware hypermarket in Europe. The store was closed last week on investigators’ orders, Kommersant reported Tuesday.

According to expert estimates carried in the Russian media, the company had sales of more than $650 million in 2007.

The retailer’s problems began last fall, when several Sunrise suppliers and banks filed lawsuits seeking more than 700 million rubles ($27 million at the time). Among them was a Vienna-based company called EAA Asset Management Consulting.

The head of the EAA Asset Management Consulting, Alexei Samoilov, told The Moscow Times that he legally represented Emma Dvornikova. He refused to comment on Mikhail Dvornikov’s relation to his company.

According to the web site Dvornikov.biz, which is registered to a Mikhail Dvornikov, he is an owner of the Vienna-based EAA Finance Management Consulting. Another company, EA Asset Management-Consulting, is 100 percent owned by Maria Dvornikova, according to an online directory of Austrian businesses.

Media reports have said Dvornikov’s wife is named Maria.

Dvornikov could not be reached for comment.

Samoilov denied that Dvornikov’s and his company were behind the crackdown on Bobylev. He said his company bought Sunrise’s debt for rent payments from Emma Dvornikova, which amounted to 100 million rubles ($3 million) as of July and that Sunrise was not paying any rent.

Baklanov, of Sunrise, said Tuesday that he could not confirm the amount of the debt but that Sunrise and Dvornikova had reached an agreement earlier this year that a certain part of the monthly rent payments would be postponed because of the economic crisis.

He added, however, that the agreement was not properly documented.

Samoilov said his EAA Asset Management Consulting, created last year, planned to buy the Stankolit site from Dvornikova but that the deal was frozen when Sunrise started transferring assets to another creditor, Alfa Group.

“I was receiving threats from Bobylev and Alfa people, and I was beaten last week,” he said. “And I understand that as easily as I was beaten, I could be buried dead.”

Samoilov said the acquisition of Stankolit would be his company’s first real estate deal in Russia.

Alfa Group was among Sunrise’s creditors, demanding 30 million rubles ($1.2 million) last fall. Samoilov said that according to his information, Sunrise’s actual debt to Alfa Group was about $30 million.

“Now, Alfa owns it all,” Samoilov said.

Alfa Group’s investment arm, A1, has taken over Sunrise’s retail chain and the brand name, Vedomosti reported earlier this month.

A1 did not respond to a request for comment Tuesday.

Baklanov said A1 owned 75 percent of Sunrise but not the brand name.


Lidia Okorokova and Alexander Velikanov contributed to this report.


Also in News

Moscow Ready for Dueling Protests

Forecasts say the temperature in Moscow will be about minus 16 degrees Celsius Saturday when tens of thousands of people will take to the streets, both in support of and in opposition to Prime Minister Vladimir Putin's run for the presidency.

Families Worry Rig Tragedy Being Swept Away

As the anti-election fraud protest at Prospekt Akademika Sakharova raged around her, Yelena Bogush seemed out of place.

Youth Group Leader in Leak Scandal

The official in charge of Russia's pro-Kremlin youth groups found himself embroiled in scandal Thursday after hackers posted links to what they claimed were thousands of his private e-mail messages.

Pro-Putin Film Twists Foes' Words

Distinguished opposition leader Mikhail Kasyanov excoriated the government in a documentary aired Wednesday night on state-controlled Channel One.

14 Million New Migrants Flocked to Russia in 2011

Almost 14 million foreigners and stateless people legally arrived in Russia last year.

Ekho Moskvy Called Extremist

A high-ranking United Russia party official said he believes liberal radio station Ekho Moskvy broke the law in publishing what he called an extremist letter by exiled tycoon and Kremlin critic Boris Berezovsky.




Discussion
The Moscow Times welcomes your comments and invites you to discuss topics with other readers. Your comment will be posted automatically to enable a live discussion. If you aren't familiar with our comments policy, you can read it here.

If you're a registered user, you can start typing your comment below. If not, take a moment to sign up. and then return to the article.

If your comment doesn't appear, contact us by using our web form.

Comments

Comments via Facebook

print


Comments

This article has no comments.

Be the first to leave a comment





Most Read