Laws 'Too Vague' To Take on MMM
28 July 1994
As thousands of panicked investors in the ailing MMM investment fund clogged Moscow streets and stock exchanges Wednesday, government officials said they had little legal basis to prosecute the company's founders if and when the reputed pyramid scheme collapses.
Andrei Kashevarov, deputy chairman of the State Anti-Trust Committee, said in an interview that the MMM joint-stock company is likely to close down, leaving at least 5 million shareholders nationwide holding worthless paper.
He acknowledged that MMM was running a classic pyramid scheme, but he said Russian law was too vague and incomplete to punish the perpetrators.
"I do not see legal grounds for instituting proceedings against MMM," he said. "The legal system has too many gaps to be effectively applied to them."
Panic spread among investors Tuesday when MMM offices in Moscow stopped redeeming the company's shares, which had grown in value from 1,600 rubles in February to 105,600 rubles by Monday (from about $1 to more than $50 dollars at the corresponding exchange rates). Thousands spent the night outside the company's headquarters on Varshavskoye Shosse in southern Moscow, hoping the morning would bring better news.
A crowd of more than 10,000 people massed outside again Wednesday, some selling their shares to speculators for between 35,000 and 70,000 rubles apiece, though most held on, hoping that the riches promised them in MMM's massive advertising campaign could still be theirs.
MMM spokesman Sergei Brish told Russian Television on Wednesday night that the headquarters would remain open 24 hours a day, and that the company's 60 offices in Moscow would reopen Friday. He did not specify whether or not the offices would be purchasing shares.
The MMM joint-stock company, one of 22 MMM divisions, took off in January when it began to guarantee the price of its own shares several days in advance and launched advertisements that portrayed average Russians who grew rich by investing in the company Kashevarov of the Anti-Trust Committee said irresponsible advertising was MMM's most evident transgression. But he said that even though at least one MMM commercial did not comply with President Boris Yeltsin's recent decree on truth in advertising, he doubted the law could be fully implemented.
An official at the Finance Ministry, who asked not to be named, agreed with Kashevarov.
"Their promises to investors were only part of an advertising campaign," the official said. "The company's charter does not state that it has to quote shares and pay a 100-percent monthly return on them. So they are not breaking any law when they stop buying them.
"We warned investors, but they wanted to take part in this race."
The official added that the Anti-Trust Committee could in theory prosecute MMM using the Law on Consumer Protection, which includes punishments for companies that sell low-quality goods or services. But he said the law would be difficult to apply to an investment company.Representatives of Russian and Western law firms, as well as officials at the State Prosecutor's Office, declined to comment on MMM's status Wednesday.
Meanwhile, Russian television stations continued to air MMM commercials, sandwiched between news reports on traffic jams and metro stoppages near the MMM headquarters.
Boris Fesenko, a deputy director of the Ostankino Television advertising agency, said his company will "within a few days" stop running an MMM commercial promising unrealistic returns on investments.
But Fesenko said Ostankino would continue to run most of the company's commercials.
"MMM is a registered company and has a right to advertise on television," Fesenko said. "Yes, this particular commercial does not comply with a presidential decree on advertising, but there is nothing wrong with their other advertisements."
Fesenko acknowledged that MMM was a principal advertiser and its shutdown could result in serious financial losses for Ostankino Television. He said, however, that Ostankino managers were more concerned about observing the law.
"We'd like to see actual documents, saying that the company's activities were illegal or its commercials were against the law, before taking any serious steps," Fesenko said.
Even though stock exchanges continued trading MMM shares Wednesday, experts said the company was collapsing. Ilya Shkabara, stock expert at the Russian Raw Materials and Commodities Exchange, said the company would not be able to recover from the current crisis.
But other officials and experts said that the company, if it bursts, can avoid court proceedings and could even reinvest in other MMM group divisions the proceeds from the pyramid scheme it appears to have run.
Sergei Skatershchikov, director of the financial consulting agency Skate-Press, was optimistic about the group's future.
"They are definitely investing in something, though it is difficult to say what exactly the investments are," he said.
Skatershchikov said that MMM was most likely investing in the shares of large privatized companies.
MMM-Invest voucher investment fund, another large division in the group, owns a 10 percent stake in Russia's largest carmaker, , according to AvtoVAZ general director Vladimir Kadannikov.
Andrei Kashevarov, deputy chairman of the State Anti-Trust Committee, said in an interview that the MMM joint-stock company is likely to close down, leaving at least 5 million shareholders nationwide holding worthless paper.
He acknowledged that MMM was running a classic pyramid scheme, but he said Russian law was too vague and incomplete to punish the perpetrators.
"I do not see legal grounds for instituting proceedings against MMM," he said. "The legal system has too many gaps to be effectively applied to them."
Panic spread among investors Tuesday when MMM offices in Moscow stopped redeeming the company's shares, which had grown in value from 1,600 rubles in February to 105,600 rubles by Monday (from about $1 to more than $50 dollars at the corresponding exchange rates). Thousands spent the night outside the company's headquarters on Varshavskoye Shosse in southern Moscow, hoping the morning would bring better news.
A crowd of more than 10,000 people massed outside again Wednesday, some selling their shares to speculators for between 35,000 and 70,000 rubles apiece, though most held on, hoping that the riches promised them in MMM's massive advertising campaign could still be theirs.
MMM spokesman Sergei Brish told Russian Television on Wednesday night that the headquarters would remain open 24 hours a day, and that the company's 60 offices in Moscow would reopen Friday. He did not specify whether or not the offices would be purchasing shares.
The MMM joint-stock company, one of 22 MMM divisions, took off in January when it began to guarantee the price of its own shares several days in advance and launched advertisements that portrayed average Russians who grew rich by investing in the company Kashevarov of the Anti-Trust Committee said irresponsible advertising was MMM's most evident transgression. But he said that even though at least one MMM commercial did not comply with President Boris Yeltsin's recent decree on truth in advertising, he doubted the law could be fully implemented.
An official at the Finance Ministry, who asked not to be named, agreed with Kashevarov.
"Their promises to investors were only part of an advertising campaign," the official said. "The company's charter does not state that it has to quote shares and pay a 100-percent monthly return on them. So they are not breaking any law when they stop buying them.
"We warned investors, but they wanted to take part in this race."
The official added that the Anti-Trust Committee could in theory prosecute MMM using the Law on Consumer Protection, which includes punishments for companies that sell low-quality goods or services. But he said the law would be difficult to apply to an investment company.Representatives of Russian and Western law firms, as well as officials at the State Prosecutor's Office, declined to comment on MMM's status Wednesday.
Meanwhile, Russian television stations continued to air MMM commercials, sandwiched between news reports on traffic jams and metro stoppages near the MMM headquarters.
Boris Fesenko, a deputy director of the Ostankino Television advertising agency, said his company will "within a few days" stop running an MMM commercial promising unrealistic returns on investments.
But Fesenko said Ostankino would continue to run most of the company's commercials.
"MMM is a registered company and has a right to advertise on television," Fesenko said. "Yes, this particular commercial does not comply with a presidential decree on advertising, but there is nothing wrong with their other advertisements."
Fesenko acknowledged that MMM was a principal advertiser and its shutdown could result in serious financial losses for Ostankino Television. He said, however, that Ostankino managers were more concerned about observing the law.
"We'd like to see actual documents, saying that the company's activities were illegal or its commercials were against the law, before taking any serious steps," Fesenko said.
Even though stock exchanges continued trading MMM shares Wednesday, experts said the company was collapsing. Ilya Shkabara, stock expert at the Russian Raw Materials and Commodities Exchange, said the company would not be able to recover from the current crisis.
But other officials and experts said that the company, if it bursts, can avoid court proceedings and could even reinvest in other MMM group divisions the proceeds from the pyramid scheme it appears to have run.
Sergei Skatershchikov, director of the financial consulting agency Skate-Press, was optimistic about the group's future.
"They are definitely investing in something, though it is difficult to say what exactly the investments are," he said.
Skatershchikov said that MMM was most likely investing in the shares of large privatized companies.
MMM-Invest voucher investment fund, another large division in the group, owns a 10 percent stake in Russia's largest carmaker, , according to AvtoVAZ general director Vladimir Kadannikov.
|
|
Tweet |
|
This article has no comments. Be the first to leave a comment |
Discussion
Comments
To post comments you must be registered
Comments via Facebook
Most Read
1.
City Mistakenly Plants Marijuana Field Instead of Lawn
After the city spread soil containing "grass" seeds around the Brateyevo metro station, a field of marijuana plants sprouted up instead of a lawn.
2.
Putin's Foreign Policy Goes on the Road
In a symbolic gesture, President Vladimir Putin on Thursday arrived in Minsk to pay his first foreign visit as head of state to controversial Belarussian leader Alexander Lukashenko.
3.
Ruble Hits Lowest Rate in 3 Years
The ruble dipped to a three-year low Thursday as oil prices fell further.
4.
European Debt Crisis Driving Workers East
Despite its inconveniences, Moscow has become a magnet for foreign job-seekers, as unemployment in Europe is hitting record highs amid the debt crisis.
5.
Superjet Flight Data Recorder Found Near Volcano Crash Site
Villagers have found the flight data recorder from the Russian plane that slammed into an Indonesian volcano three weeks ago, killing 45 people.
6.
Businessman Shot in Central Moscow
A prominent business leader was shot and wounded by three masked men in the heart of Moscow on Friday — just steps away from FSB headquarters.
7.
Duma Deputy Robbed at Ritzy Hotel
State Duma Deputy Gennady Gudkov was robbed at the upscale Hotel National across from the street from the Kremlin after a conference, Gudkov said Wednesday evening.
8.
China-Russia Airplane Venture Planned
United Aircraft Corporation and Chinese Commercial Aircraft Corporation plan to start a joint venture to develop long-haul aircraft.
9.
Fridman Wants Big Change at TNK-BP
TNK-BP co-owner Mikhail Fridman said BP's Soviet-born partners are urging the British company to return to talks about changing the proportion of the 50-50 partnership.
10.
Russian Railways in Smoking Crackdown, Privatization Freeze
Smokers will find train journeys longer and a tad more frustrating as traditional indulgence of the habit is phased out on Russian Railways' passenger routes.
1.
City Mistakenly Plants Marijuana Field Instead of Lawn
After the city spread soil containing "grass" seeds around the Brateyevo metro station, a field of marijuana plants sprouted up instead of a lawn.
2.
Tabloid: Superjet Downed by U.S. Industrial Sabotage
A tabloid claims that Russian intelligence agencies are investigating the possibility that the U.S. military may have brought down the Sukhoi Superjet that crashed in Indonesia.
3.
McFaul Faces Kremlin Scorn Once Again
The Foreign Ministry assailed U.S. Ambassador Michael McFaul for comments the ministry said went "far beyond the bounds of diplomatic etiquette."
4.
Sweden Wins Eurovision; Grannies Take Second
Sweden’s Loreen won the Eurovision Song Contest in Azerbaijan on Sunday before an international TV audience of 100 million, days after angering Azeri authorities by meeting rights activists critical of the host country’s human rights record.
5.
Red Square Flyboy Regrets Air Stunt
When Mathias Rust landed his white Cessna on Red Square on May 28, 1987, he had placed all his hopes for world peace in Mikhail Gorbachev.
6.
Protest and Chaos Seen in Kudrin-Ordered Study
Continued protests in Russia will likely lead to violence or chaotic change, according to a new study ordered by the former finance minister.
7.
Russia's New Propaganda Minister
After Monday's announcement that historian Vladimir Medinsky was appointed the culture minister, critics quickly labeled him the new propaganda minister. Medinsky's academic ethics and historical distortions may raise serious questions, but for the Kremlin, he has three important attributes that are much more important: He is a model United Russia leader, a firm Putin loyalist and a skilled sophist.
8.
Ukraine in Uproar Over Status of Russian Language
Ukraine's ruling party has triggered violent protests with a move to upgrade the official role of Russian, a sensitive issue opponents say will split the country.
9.
150 Detained at Anti-Kremlin Rallies
About 150 people were detained Sunday as scores of people gathered for a series of anti-government demonstrations in Moscow and St. Petersburg.
10.
Vkontakte Founder Tosses 5,000-Ruble Notes Out Window
<p>The founder of the social networking site Vkontakte celebrated St. Petersburg’s 309th anniversary over the weekend by tossing paper airplanes carrying 5,000-ruble notes out a building window.</p>
1.
Hundreds of Arrests Set Grim Backdrop for Victory Day Celebrations
As Moscow gears up to celebrate its victory in World War II, 67 years ago Wednesday, the shadow of political conflict shrouds the capital as hundreds of arrests cloud Victory Day festivities.
2.
City Mistakenly Plants Marijuana Field Instead of Lawn
After the city spread soil containing "grass" seeds around the Brateyevo metro station, a field of marijuana plants sprouted up instead of a lawn.
3.
Russian Satellite Takes Highest-Ever Resolution Picture of Earth
A stunning 121-megapixel snapshot of the Earth was taken by a Russian weather satellite in what is thought to be the highest resolution picture of the planet ever taken from space.
4.
Bodies, No Survivors Spotted at Superjet Crash
Search and rescue helicopters and volunteers struggling through thick forest and mountainous terrain spotted bodies but no survivors on the Indonesian mountainside where a Sukhoi Superjet 100 crashed by the time darkness forced an end to the search Thursday night.
5.
Tabloid: Superjet Downed by U.S. Industrial Sabotage
A tabloid claims that Russian intelligence agencies are investigating the possibility that the U.S. military may have brought down the Sukhoi Superjet that crashed in Indonesia.
6.
Mysterious Photos Reveal an Unseen WWII
After the end of World War II, Paul Sadler returned home to Chicago with three German books and a photo album from the Dachau concentration camp.
7.
Furniture Magnate Shot Dead in Mercedes in Moscow Region
A 46-year-old furniture magnate was killed with six gunshot wounds to the head and chest early Sunday as he arrived in his Mercedes at his home in the Moscow region.
8.
Vladivostok Bridge Climbers Fined 300 Rubles Each
Three thrill-seekers who climbed two Vladivostok bridges earlier this week and took photos from the top were fined 300 rubles ($10) each for trespassing.
9.
New Cabinet Has Familiar Cast of Characters
President Vladimir Putin on Monday announced the makeup of the new Cabinet answering to Putin and Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev, with three-fourths of the members having been replaced.
10.
Superjet Missing in Indonesia With 50 on Board
A dark cloud was cast Wednesday on the revival of Russia’s aviation industry when a Sukhoi-built Superjet 100 with 50 people on board disappeared from the radar screens of Indonesian flight controllers.


