Court Joins War of Reason Over Force
10 February 1995
Russia's Constitutional Court will reconvene for the first time in more than a year Monday to consider roughly 70 cases, ranging from complaints about unpaid back wages and confiscated apartments to the defunct Supreme Soviet's request that former vice president Alexander Rutskoi be reinstated in his post.
After the opening plenary session, the 19-member high court will split up into two chambers, elect a new chairman and start plowing through the caseload accumulated since 1993. About half of those complaints came in last year during the court's period of forced inaction.
After its October 1993 suspension by President Boris Yeltsin for siding with the rebellious Supreme Soviet, the court must now redefine itself and deal with a number of political matters from an earlier era.
The new court will face the challenge of interpreting a new constitution -- approved in a referendum 14 months ago -- that gives much stronger powers to the president.
Former court chairman Valery Zorkin said he has his doubts about the future role of the revamped court, which kept its 13 initial members but got six new judges after a painstaking five-month selection process in the Federation Council.
"The old court turned out to be inconvenient for the executive, so it was decided to water it down and go from 13 judges to 19," Zorkin said in an interview Thursday. "But the important thing is, will they stop at that? Will it still be 19 judges and not 27 or 12 when the next president comes? We've let the genie out of the bottle."
The Constitutional Court, the only body in Russia allowed to interpret the constitution and make binding decisions to annul presidential and government decrees, sees itself as the branch of power that must prevail upon the other branches to use reason over force.
But it was by sheer force that Yeltsin suspended the old court, Zorkin said, adding that Russian society had failed to support the very body that is appointed to defend its civil rights from government high-handedness.
"I would like society to realize that it needs the Constitutional Court," Zorkin said. "Past experience shows that society turned out to be unable to defend the court."
Viktor Borisyuk, an analyst with Yeltsin's Information and Analysis Center, said there was still a chance that the new court would end up as the old one did.
"It's possible, considering the state of our legislative base and the personal relationships of the people involved," Borisyuk said, pointing out that the judges who had been suspended might bear the president a grudge. "But it's a different era now, and if we're lucky, history will not repeat itself."
The uncertainty over the court's future is reflected in its relatively small caseload at present, which sharply contrasts with about 17,000 complaints received in a year by the old court, according to Zorkin. Many were redirected to other courts. The new law on the Constitutional Court stipulates that there should be two chambers, one numbering nine judges and the other 10. That way, Zorkin said, judges would be able to sort through the cases faster. Judges will draw lots Monday to determine the chamber membership.
However, only the plenary session of the court, with all 19 judges sitting at a long table in their purple robes of office, is empowered to interpret the constitution and rule on charges of unconstitutional behavior against the president. Zorkin said it would be harder for the unwieldy, 19-member court to make important decisions than it had been for the old, smaller one.
On Monday, the judges will decide which of the 70 cases they will consider and which ones they will reject or forward to other courts. Prominent on the list is former parliament speaker Ruslan Khasbulatov's request that the court consider the legality of Yeltsin firing his second-in-command, Rutskoi, in 1993.
"In legal terms, if the court decided the firing was illegal, Rutskoi would be reinstated," Zorkin said. "But it's easy to guess that this case will be dropped. It's from another era."
The new constitution does not provide for the head of state to have a vice president.
On the other hand, there are newer requests from regional courts to check the constitutionality of a criminal-code provision that anyone imprisoned for six months or more must give up his or her apartment. And there is the obligatory nagging complaint that just won't go away.
"This guy has nagged us for five years about some back pay he is owed," Zorkin said as he went through the list. "We could not help him and we tried to refer him to another court, but there are complainers like this."
There is still no query at the court about the constitutionality of the war in Chechnya, although the Communist Party has said that it will lodge such a query as soon as the court reconvenes. According to Zorkin, Chechnya will probably take precedence over other scheduled cases if it comes up in court.
"If there are massive human-rights violations and deaths, such a matter cannot wait its turn," Zorkin said. "Otherwise there will be no court, no people and no problem left by the time we get to it."
After the opening plenary session, the 19-member high court will split up into two chambers, elect a new chairman and start plowing through the caseload accumulated since 1993. About half of those complaints came in last year during the court's period of forced inaction.
After its October 1993 suspension by President Boris Yeltsin for siding with the rebellious Supreme Soviet, the court must now redefine itself and deal with a number of political matters from an earlier era.
The new court will face the challenge of interpreting a new constitution -- approved in a referendum 14 months ago -- that gives much stronger powers to the president.
Former court chairman Valery Zorkin said he has his doubts about the future role of the revamped court, which kept its 13 initial members but got six new judges after a painstaking five-month selection process in the Federation Council.
"The old court turned out to be inconvenient for the executive, so it was decided to water it down and go from 13 judges to 19," Zorkin said in an interview Thursday. "But the important thing is, will they stop at that? Will it still be 19 judges and not 27 or 12 when the next president comes? We've let the genie out of the bottle."
The Constitutional Court, the only body in Russia allowed to interpret the constitution and make binding decisions to annul presidential and government decrees, sees itself as the branch of power that must prevail upon the other branches to use reason over force.
But it was by sheer force that Yeltsin suspended the old court, Zorkin said, adding that Russian society had failed to support the very body that is appointed to defend its civil rights from government high-handedness.
"I would like society to realize that it needs the Constitutional Court," Zorkin said. "Past experience shows that society turned out to be unable to defend the court."
Viktor Borisyuk, an analyst with Yeltsin's Information and Analysis Center, said there was still a chance that the new court would end up as the old one did.
"It's possible, considering the state of our legislative base and the personal relationships of the people involved," Borisyuk said, pointing out that the judges who had been suspended might bear the president a grudge. "But it's a different era now, and if we're lucky, history will not repeat itself."
The uncertainty over the court's future is reflected in its relatively small caseload at present, which sharply contrasts with about 17,000 complaints received in a year by the old court, according to Zorkin. Many were redirected to other courts. The new law on the Constitutional Court stipulates that there should be two chambers, one numbering nine judges and the other 10. That way, Zorkin said, judges would be able to sort through the cases faster. Judges will draw lots Monday to determine the chamber membership.
However, only the plenary session of the court, with all 19 judges sitting at a long table in their purple robes of office, is empowered to interpret the constitution and rule on charges of unconstitutional behavior against the president. Zorkin said it would be harder for the unwieldy, 19-member court to make important decisions than it had been for the old, smaller one.
On Monday, the judges will decide which of the 70 cases they will consider and which ones they will reject or forward to other courts. Prominent on the list is former parliament speaker Ruslan Khasbulatov's request that the court consider the legality of Yeltsin firing his second-in-command, Rutskoi, in 1993.
"In legal terms, if the court decided the firing was illegal, Rutskoi would be reinstated," Zorkin said. "But it's easy to guess that this case will be dropped. It's from another era."
The new constitution does not provide for the head of state to have a vice president.
On the other hand, there are newer requests from regional courts to check the constitutionality of a criminal-code provision that anyone imprisoned for six months or more must give up his or her apartment. And there is the obligatory nagging complaint that just won't go away.
"This guy has nagged us for five years about some back pay he is owed," Zorkin said as he went through the list. "We could not help him and we tried to refer him to another court, but there are complainers like this."
There is still no query at the court about the constitutionality of the war in Chechnya, although the Communist Party has said that it will lodge such a query as soon as the court reconvenes. According to Zorkin, Chechnya will probably take precedence over other scheduled cases if it comes up in court.
"If there are massive human-rights violations and deaths, such a matter cannot wait its turn," Zorkin said. "Otherwise there will be no court, no people and no problem left by the time we get to it."
|
|
Tweet |
|
This article has no comments. Be the first to leave a comment |
Discussion
Comments
To post comments you must be registered
Comments via Facebook
Most Read
1.
Prominent Businessman Shot Near FSB Headquarters
A prominent business leader was shot and wounded by three masked men in the heart of Moscow on Friday — just steps away from FSB headquarters.
2.
BP Confirms Effort to Sell its TNK-BP Stake
BP has agreed to consider quitting its Russian joint venture in a move that could strip the British company of almost a third of its output and reverse the biggest investment in the Russian oil industry.
3.
Weak Ruble Bad for Some, But Not All
The Central Bank has begun large-scale intervention in currency markets as steadily slumping oil prices stoked the plunge of the ruble to levels not seen in three years.
4.
Putin Denies Russian Role in Syrian Violence
Under mounting international pressure, President Vladimir Putin denied that Moscow is fueling bloodshed in Syria with arms exports and that Russia unilaterally supports the government in Damascus.
5.
In Belarus, Putin Puts Emphasis on Economic Ties
In his first trip abroad since reclaiming the presidency, Vladimir Putin promised to extend more credit to Belarus as both countries agreed to accelerate joint economic projects including the construction of a nuclear power plant.
6.
Russia's Role in the Houla Massacre
The Syrian problem has become a vicious vortex sucking the Russian ship downward into its maw.
7.
Putin Awards Large Families in Kremlin Palace
President Vladimir Putin awarded parents of large families at a ceremony in a luxurious Kremlin palace over the weekend, celebrating families with as many as 13 children.
<br />
<br />
8.
Ukrainian Analyst, Invited by Opposition, Barred at Airport
A prominent Ukrainian political scientist was barred entry to Russia when he arrived in Moscow at the invitation of the Solidarity opposition group.
9.
Magnitsky Bill to Get Vote Thursday
U.S. lawmakers plan to vote on the "Magnitsky List" legislation this week, raising the specter of a harsh response from the Kremlin.
10.
Chechnya's Kadyrov Refuses to 'March' to U.S. Orders
Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov has angrily accused the United States of lecturing him on human rights and demanding that Chechens "march" to its orders.
1.
City Mistakenly Plants Marijuana Field Instead of Lawn
After the city spread soil containing "grass" seeds around the Brateyevo metro station, a field of marijuana plants sprouted up instead of a lawn.
2.
McFaul Faces Kremlin Scorn Once Again
The Foreign Ministry assailed U.S. Ambassador Michael McFaul for comments the ministry said went "far beyond the bounds of diplomatic etiquette."
3.
Sweden Wins Eurovision; Grannies Take Second
Sweden’s Loreen won the Eurovision Song Contest in Azerbaijan on Sunday before an international TV audience of 100 million, days after angering Azeri authorities by meeting rights activists critical of the host country’s human rights record.
4.
Ukraine in Uproar Over Status of Russian Language
Ukraine's ruling party has triggered violent protests with a move to upgrade the official role of Russian, a sensitive issue opponents say will split the country.
5.
Vkontakte Founder Tosses 5,000-Ruble Notes Out Window
<p>The founder of the social networking site Vkontakte celebrated St. Petersburg’s 309th anniversary over the weekend by tossing paper airplanes carrying 5,000-ruble notes out a building window.</p>
6.
150 Detained at Anti-Kremlin Rallies
About 150 people were detained Sunday as scores of people gathered for a series of anti-government demonstrations in Moscow and St. Petersburg.
7.
U.S.-Russian 3-Year Multientry Visa Bill to Go to Duma
After months of delays, the government has finalized a much-touted visa agreement with the United States and drafted the corresponding bill.
8.
Putin's Final Act
Russians are usually patient and slow to rebel, but once they have turned on their leader, they don't stop until he is out.
9.
Putin's Foreign Policy Goes on the Road
In a symbolic gesture, President Vladimir Putin on Thursday arrived in Minsk to pay his first foreign visit as head of state to controversial Belarussian leader Alexander Lukashenko.
10.
Kennan's Insight Into the Russian Soul
George Kennan is best known as the author of the containment policy, which served as the overarching principle informing U.S. foreign policy during the Cold War.
1.
Hundreds of Arrests Set Grim Backdrop for Victory Day Celebrations
As Moscow gears up to celebrate its victory in World War II, 67 years ago Wednesday, the shadow of political conflict shrouds the capital as hundreds of arrests cloud Victory Day festivities.
2.
City Mistakenly Plants Marijuana Field Instead of Lawn
After the city spread soil containing "grass" seeds around the Brateyevo metro station, a field of marijuana plants sprouted up instead of a lawn.
3.
Russian Satellite Takes Highest-Ever Resolution Picture of Earth
A stunning 121-megapixel snapshot of the Earth was taken by a Russian weather satellite in what is thought to be the highest resolution picture of the planet ever taken from space.
4.
Bodies, No Survivors Spotted at Superjet Crash
Search and rescue helicopters and volunteers struggling through thick forest and mountainous terrain spotted bodies but no survivors on the Indonesian mountainside where a Sukhoi Superjet 100 crashed by the time darkness forced an end to the search Thursday night.
5.
Tabloid: Superjet Downed by U.S. Industrial Sabotage
A tabloid claims that Russian intelligence agencies are investigating the possibility that the U.S. military may have brought down the Sukhoi Superjet that crashed in Indonesia.
6.
Mysterious Photos Reveal an Unseen WWII
After the end of World War II, Paul Sadler returned home to Chicago with three German books and a photo album from the Dachau concentration camp.
7.
Furniture Magnate Shot Dead in Mercedes in Moscow Region
A 46-year-old furniture magnate was killed with six gunshot wounds to the head and chest early Sunday as he arrived in his Mercedes at his home in the Moscow region.
8.
Vladivostok Bridge Climbers Fined 300 Rubles Each
Three thrill-seekers who climbed two Vladivostok bridges earlier this week and took photos from the top were fined 300 rubles ($10) each for trespassing.
9.
New Cabinet Has Familiar Cast of Characters
President Vladimir Putin on Monday announced the makeup of the new Cabinet answering to Putin and Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev, with three-fourths of the members having been replaced.
10.
Superjet Missing in Indonesia With 50 on Board
A dark cloud was cast Wednesday on the revival of Russia’s aviation industry when a Sukhoi-built Superjet 100 with 50 people on board disappeared from the radar screens of Indonesian flight controllers.


