A Battle for the Lips and Noses of Moscow
04 November 1994
By Anne Barnard
In 1989, Estee Lauder came to town, spent about $1 million renovating a central Moscow storefront and turned Perfumery No. 36 into the Soviet Union's first foreign-run boutique, a splash of color and opulence in a row of drab, empty stores with names like "Cheese" and "Groceries."
The cosmetics giant struck a retail gold mine: Lines snaked out the door of the shop on what then was called Gorky Street as Muscovites and busloads of Soviet tourists gawked at an unheard-of selection of lipsticks and perfumes and bought up to $10 million worth of Estee Lauder products a year.
All that changed in 1992. Seizing an opportunity under early privatization rules, the store's Russian employees took over the premises, locked out the company, changed the sign from "Estee Lauder" to "Perfumery" and turned the boutique back into shop No. 36.
Shop No. 36 got the gleaming new doors, windows and sleek display cases that make it hard to mix up with Nos. 35 and 37, and Estee Lauder got mad. The company has been fighting ever since to regain control of the store at the foot of Tverskaya Ulitsa, which is now Moscow's equivalent of a prime retail spot on New York's Fifth Avenue.
"We put in everything -- floors, windows, doors, walls, wiring, plumbing, air conditioning, telephones, furniture," said Elizabeth Susskind, director of Estee Lauder's operations in Russia. "It's as if you were sitting on my couch and suddenly it became yours just because you were Russian and you happened to be sitting there when privatization came along."
Store personnel refused to discuss the conflict and said they had no connection to Estee Lauder.
"The store is independent," said one administrator, who refused to give her name. "It always was. What else could it be? We are working here on Soviet soil."
Estee Lauder goes to court next week to try to force the employees' eviction. Susskind said a victory would score points for common sense and make other foreigners "more secure about having an investment here."
And in that quest the company has a powerful ally: Mayor Yury Luzhkov.
Mayoral spokesman Igor Zverev said Luzhkov is personally supporting Estee Lauder in order "to show that the Mosco Karakozov, but were dropped for lack of evidence. Karakozov, once the head of the Defense Ministry's Trade Administration, now works in the Air Force's maintenance division.
But the murder of Dmitry Kholodov, 27, a journalist investigating illegal activities in the Western Group, has brought the accusations back to the top of the news. On Tuesday, howls from the Russian media toppled the Western Group's last commander, First Deputy Defense Minister Matvei Burlakov.
Yeltsin's dismissal of Burlakov culminated an investigation that Boldyrev began as long as three years ago, following widespread reports in the Western press that demoralized Soviet troops stationed in East Germany had begun a fire sale of equipment and resources after the fall of the Berlin Wall in December 1989.
But Boldyrev's buried investigation became a political football in the battle between Yeltsin and the former Supreme Soviet. Former Public Prosecutor Valentin Stepankov told the legislature he had documentary evidence directly implicating Defense Minister Pavel Grachev in the scandal. But apart from Boldyrev's report, none of the supposed evidence was ever made public.
Since then, the ball has been picked up primarily by journalists such as Kholodov. In a series of articles, he went on to allege that there was a mafia operating within the armed forces.
"Our Russian Army is sliding into the world of organized crime," he wrote in August. "A well-organized, disciplined and strictly hierarchical mafia structure is coming to us from the (Western Group)."
In the meantime, the Public Prosecutor's Office has been conducting a series of minor investigations into illegal activity in the Western Group, but no evidence of widespread corruption has been found, according to spokesman Alexander Zvyagentsev.
Sergei Ushakov, a spokesman for the Military Prosecutor's Office, said his office was investigating four cases of "abuse of military power" in the Western Group, but that these did not involve top level officers.
Sergei Yushenkov, chairman of the State Duma's defense committee, intends to hold hearings on the same matter in about two weeks. In preparation, Yushenkov has asked the Federal Counterintelligence Service, the Defense Ministry and the Customs Control Committee to turn over any relevant information they had. On Thursday he got his first answer, from the counterintelligence service. "The documents are secret, but I can say this: They confirm that there is corruption in the Western Group," Yushenkov said.
An examination of illegal arms sales is not the only investigation touching on the military's highest echelons. A team of investigators led by the Public Prosecutor's Office is now pouring over the Kholodov's murder.
Fyodor Ladygin, head of military intelligence, claims "foreign espionage services" are to blame for Kholodov's death, but he may have a tough time convincing the public of that.
"The investigation is headed by one of the office's senior prosecutors," Zvyagentsev said. Acting Public Prosecutor Alexei Ilyushenko, Federal Counterintelligence Service Director Sergei Stepashin and First Deputy Interior Minister Mikhail Yegorov met Tuesday to discuss strategy.
On Thursday, Stepashin announced that the murder was "definitely political," aimed at destabilizing Russia's armed forces, Itar-Tass reported.w government keeps its word to foreign investors: If they invest money here, they will be allowed to keep on developing."
Luzhkov has come under fire from some foreign business people who say his conservative approach to privatization threatens investment security because it gives city officials tight control over privatized enterprises and favors long-term rent over private ownership.
Susskind, though, says Luzhkov has fought to save Estee Lauder's investment from the beginning.
In 1992, Moscow launched its first privatization program, under which most of the city's shops, restaurants and other small enterprises were handed over to employee collectives for largely symbolic sums. Workers at state-run bread stores, grocery stores and shoe repairs were privatizing left and right, and Estee Lauder's employees, who were inherited from Perfumery No. 36, were watching.
"Our employees saw pennies from heaven," said Susskind. She said Estee Lauder offered the 40 employees a deal under which they would get 25-year work contracts, share profits and own 5 to 10 percent of the store -- the percentage of the store's value that came from Soviet state property.
"Their attitude was, 'You're offering us a bribe,'" said Susskind. "They wanted it all."
Luzhkov, then deputy mayor, issued a special decree on behalf of Estee Lauder and other early Western stores saying that because of their investments they should be allowed to "participate in privatization." Susskind thought the problem was solved.
Then the Moscow Property Committee wrote to say it was about to approve Estee Lauder's application for privatization -- an application Susskind said was never submitted.
The employees, she said, had made up Estee Lauder stationery and an Estee Lauder stamp and forged a letter authorizing privatization.
Store director Olga Bazhennova demanded Estee Lauder lease the store back from them, continue paying for renovation and maintenance, and supply goods on consignment, Susskind said. Instead, the company walked out.
With help from top city officials, Estee Lauder won a court ruling that the takeover was illegal because only wholly state-owned entities could be privatized, said their lawyer, Mikhail Korobkov.
But the workers stayed put. With the help of the Moscow City Council, now dissolved, they had obtained a lease, Susskind said. A sign appeared in the window with the name of their new firm, apparently named for the director: Olga.
Estee Lauder is now suing the Moscow government -- which plans to lose, Korobkov said -- in order to get a court eviction order stating that the workers' lease violates the company's prior contract with the city.
The cosmetics giant struck a retail gold mine: Lines snaked out the door of the shop on what then was called Gorky Street as Muscovites and busloads of Soviet tourists gawked at an unheard-of selection of lipsticks and perfumes and bought up to $10 million worth of Estee Lauder products a year.
All that changed in 1992. Seizing an opportunity under early privatization rules, the store's Russian employees took over the premises, locked out the company, changed the sign from "Estee Lauder" to "Perfumery" and turned the boutique back into shop No. 36.
Shop No. 36 got the gleaming new doors, windows and sleek display cases that make it hard to mix up with Nos. 35 and 37, and Estee Lauder got mad. The company has been fighting ever since to regain control of the store at the foot of Tverskaya Ulitsa, which is now Moscow's equivalent of a prime retail spot on New York's Fifth Avenue.
"We put in everything -- floors, windows, doors, walls, wiring, plumbing, air conditioning, telephones, furniture," said Elizabeth Susskind, director of Estee Lauder's operations in Russia. "It's as if you were sitting on my couch and suddenly it became yours just because you were Russian and you happened to be sitting there when privatization came along."
Store personnel refused to discuss the conflict and said they had no connection to Estee Lauder.
"The store is independent," said one administrator, who refused to give her name. "It always was. What else could it be? We are working here on Soviet soil."
Estee Lauder goes to court next week to try to force the employees' eviction. Susskind said a victory would score points for common sense and make other foreigners "more secure about having an investment here."
And in that quest the company has a powerful ally: Mayor Yury Luzhkov.
Mayoral spokesman Igor Zverev said Luzhkov is personally supporting Estee Lauder in order "to show that the Mosco Karakozov, but were dropped for lack of evidence. Karakozov, once the head of the Defense Ministry's Trade Administration, now works in the Air Force's maintenance division.
But the murder of Dmitry Kholodov, 27, a journalist investigating illegal activities in the Western Group, has brought the accusations back to the top of the news. On Tuesday, howls from the Russian media toppled the Western Group's last commander, First Deputy Defense Minister Matvei Burlakov.
Yeltsin's dismissal of Burlakov culminated an investigation that Boldyrev began as long as three years ago, following widespread reports in the Western press that demoralized Soviet troops stationed in East Germany had begun a fire sale of equipment and resources after the fall of the Berlin Wall in December 1989.
But Boldyrev's buried investigation became a political football in the battle between Yeltsin and the former Supreme Soviet. Former Public Prosecutor Valentin Stepankov told the legislature he had documentary evidence directly implicating Defense Minister Pavel Grachev in the scandal. But apart from Boldyrev's report, none of the supposed evidence was ever made public.
Since then, the ball has been picked up primarily by journalists such as Kholodov. In a series of articles, he went on to allege that there was a mafia operating within the armed forces.
"Our Russian Army is sliding into the world of organized crime," he wrote in August. "A well-organized, disciplined and strictly hierarchical mafia structure is coming to us from the (Western Group)."
In the meantime, the Public Prosecutor's Office has been conducting a series of minor investigations into illegal activity in the Western Group, but no evidence of widespread corruption has been found, according to spokesman Alexander Zvyagentsev.
Sergei Ushakov, a spokesman for the Military Prosecutor's Office, said his office was investigating four cases of "abuse of military power" in the Western Group, but that these did not involve top level officers.
Sergei Yushenkov, chairman of the State Duma's defense committee, intends to hold hearings on the same matter in about two weeks. In preparation, Yushenkov has asked the Federal Counterintelligence Service, the Defense Ministry and the Customs Control Committee to turn over any relevant information they had. On Thursday he got his first answer, from the counterintelligence service. "The documents are secret, but I can say this: They confirm that there is corruption in the Western Group," Yushenkov said.
An examination of illegal arms sales is not the only investigation touching on the military's highest echelons. A team of investigators led by the Public Prosecutor's Office is now pouring over the Kholodov's murder.
Fyodor Ladygin, head of military intelligence, claims "foreign espionage services" are to blame for Kholodov's death, but he may have a tough time convincing the public of that.
"The investigation is headed by one of the office's senior prosecutors," Zvyagentsev said. Acting Public Prosecutor Alexei Ilyushenko, Federal Counterintelligence Service Director Sergei Stepashin and First Deputy Interior Minister Mikhail Yegorov met Tuesday to discuss strategy.
On Thursday, Stepashin announced that the murder was "definitely political," aimed at destabilizing Russia's armed forces, Itar-Tass reported.w government keeps its word to foreign investors: If they invest money here, they will be allowed to keep on developing."
Luzhkov has come under fire from some foreign business people who say his conservative approach to privatization threatens investment security because it gives city officials tight control over privatized enterprises and favors long-term rent over private ownership.
Susskind, though, says Luzhkov has fought to save Estee Lauder's investment from the beginning.
In 1992, Moscow launched its first privatization program, under which most of the city's shops, restaurants and other small enterprises were handed over to employee collectives for largely symbolic sums. Workers at state-run bread stores, grocery stores and shoe repairs were privatizing left and right, and Estee Lauder's employees, who were inherited from Perfumery No. 36, were watching.
"Our employees saw pennies from heaven," said Susskind. She said Estee Lauder offered the 40 employees a deal under which they would get 25-year work contracts, share profits and own 5 to 10 percent of the store -- the percentage of the store's value that came from Soviet state property.
"Their attitude was, 'You're offering us a bribe,'" said Susskind. "They wanted it all."
Luzhkov, then deputy mayor, issued a special decree on behalf of Estee Lauder and other early Western stores saying that because of their investments they should be allowed to "participate in privatization." Susskind thought the problem was solved.
Then the Moscow Property Committee wrote to say it was about to approve Estee Lauder's application for privatization -- an application Susskind said was never submitted.
The employees, she said, had made up Estee Lauder stationery and an Estee Lauder stamp and forged a letter authorizing privatization.
Store director Olga Bazhennova demanded Estee Lauder lease the store back from them, continue paying for renovation and maintenance, and supply goods on consignment, Susskind said. Instead, the company walked out.
With help from top city officials, Estee Lauder won a court ruling that the takeover was illegal because only wholly state-owned entities could be privatized, said their lawyer, Mikhail Korobkov.
But the workers stayed put. With the help of the Moscow City Council, now dissolved, they had obtained a lease, Susskind said. A sign appeared in the window with the name of their new firm, apparently named for the director: Olga.
Estee Lauder is now suing the Moscow government -- which plans to lose, Korobkov said -- in order to get a court eviction order stating that the workers' lease violates the company's prior contract with the city.
|
|
Tweet |
|
This article has no comments. Be the first to leave a comment |
Discussion
Comments
To post comments you must be registered
Comments via Facebook
Most Read
1.
McFaul Faces Kremlin Scorn Once Again
The Foreign Ministry assailed U.S. Ambassador Michael McFaul for comments the ministry said went "far beyond the bounds of diplomatic etiquette."
2.
Berezovsky Investigated for Inciting 'Mass Disorder'
The Investigative Committee has opened an inquiry against self-exiled businessman Boris Berezovsky, who recently pledged a $1.5 million bounty for the arrest of Vladimir Putin.
3.
Radio Journalist Stabbed Outside Apartment Building
A journalist for Mayak radio was clinging to life Tuesday after being stabbed outside his apartment building by an unknown attacker.
4.
Chernobyl Horror Film Called Disrespectful, A Joke
Horror film "Chernobyl Diaries," with its ghostly tale of terror near the infamous, abandoned nuclear plant hits theaters after protests that it sensationalizes a disaster that had tragic human consequences.
5.
Ukraine's Behavior in WTO Has Negotiators Scratching Their Heads
Laos, a small nation dependent on aid and rice farming, wants to join the World Trade Organization. WTO powers including the United States, China and the European Union want it to.
6.
Suspect Detained in Killing of Furniture Magnate
An alleged organizer of a murder of Russian furniture magnate Mikhail Kravchenko has been detained in the Moscow region.
7.
Russky Island Getting Posh on Schedule
After global leaders conclude the annual Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum in September, the purpose-built $2.3 billion conference center on a remote island off the coast of Vladivostok will become a university.
8.
The Nixon Option for Iran
Boldness of the sort displayed by U.S. President Richard Nixon in opening discussions with China is needed now in the negotiations over Iran's nuclear program.
9.
$13.4Bln Football Bill Puts Ukraine in the Hole
Ukraine may never recover all of the billions of dollars it has spent to co-host next month's European football championship, and the outlay might complicate its chances of servicing its debt.
10.
Husband Stabs Wife in Bank, Writes 'I Love You' in Blood on Window
The estranged husband of a Sberbank employee in the Primorye region fatally stabbed his wife in the bank Tuesday — scrawling the chilling message “Yulia, I love you” in blood on a window before being arrested.
1.
Tabloid: Superjet Downed by U.S. Industrial Sabotage
A tabloid claims that Russian intelligence agencies are investigating the possibility that the U.S. military may have brought down the Sukhoi Superjet that crashed in Indonesia.
2.
McFaul Faces Kremlin Scorn Once Again
The Foreign Ministry assailed U.S. Ambassador Michael McFaul for comments the ministry said went "far beyond the bounds of diplomatic etiquette."
3.
Red Square Flyboy Regrets Air Stunt
When Mathias Rust landed his white Cessna on Red Square on May 28, 1987, he had placed all his hopes for world peace in Mikhail Gorbachev.
4.
Sweden Wins Eurovision; Grannies Take Second
Sweden’s Loreen won the Eurovision Song Contest in Azerbaijan on Sunday before an international TV audience of 100 million, days after angering Azeri authorities by meeting rights activists critical of the host country’s human rights record.
5.
Village Grannies Make It to Eurovision Finals
Russia's group Buranovskiye Babushki has made it into the finals of the Eurovision Song Contest in Baku, Azerbaijan, bringing the elderly folk singers from a far-off Russian village to the attention of more than 100 million viewers around the world.
6.
Protest and Chaos Seen in Kudrin-Ordered Study
Continued protests in Russia will likely lead to violence or chaotic change, according to a new study ordered by the former finance minister.
7.
Ukraine in Uproar Over Status of Russian Language
Ukraine's ruling party has triggered violent protests with a move to upgrade the official role of Russian, a sensitive issue opponents say will split the country.
8.
150 Detained at Anti-Kremlin Rallies
About 150 people were detained Sunday as scores of people gathered for a series of anti-government demonstrations in Moscow and St. Petersburg.
9.
Tensions Rise as Opposition Leaders are Freed
Sergei Udaltsov and Alexei Navalny emerged from prison Thursday, while a dramatic standoff erupted at a State Duma hearing over a bill that would hike fines for illegal demonstrations.
10.
More Public Figures Accused of Flouting Road Rules
Following the president's order to cut the number of officials entitled to use flashing lights to skirt through traffic, several incidents of alleged abuse involving high-profile figures have come to light.
1.
Hundreds of Arrests Set Grim Backdrop for Victory Day Celebrations
As Moscow gears up to celebrate its victory in World War II, 67 years ago Wednesday, the shadow of political conflict shrouds the capital as hundreds of arrests cloud Victory Day festivities.
2.
Russian Satellite Takes Highest-Ever Resolution Picture of Earth
A stunning 121-megapixel snapshot of the Earth was taken by a Russian weather satellite in what is thought to be the highest resolution picture of the planet ever taken from space.
3.
Bodies, No Survivors Spotted at Superjet Crash
Search and rescue helicopters and volunteers struggling through thick forest and mountainous terrain spotted bodies but no survivors on the Indonesian mountainside where a Sukhoi Superjet 100 crashed by the time darkness forced an end to the search Thursday night.
4.
Tabloid: Superjet Downed by U.S. Industrial Sabotage
A tabloid claims that Russian intelligence agencies are investigating the possibility that the U.S. military may have brought down the Sukhoi Superjet that crashed in Indonesia.
5.
Mysterious Photos Reveal an Unseen WWII
After the end of World War II, Paul Sadler returned home to Chicago with three German books and a photo album from the Dachau concentration camp.
6.
Furniture Magnate Shot Dead in Mercedes in Moscow Region
A 46-year-old furniture magnate was killed with six gunshot wounds to the head and chest early Sunday as he arrived in his Mercedes at his home in the Moscow region.
7.
Vladivostok Bridge Climbers Fined 300 Rubles Each
Three thrill-seekers who climbed two Vladivostok bridges earlier this week and took photos from the top were fined 300 rubles ($10) each for trespassing.
8.
New Cabinet Has Familiar Cast of Characters
President Vladimir Putin on Monday announced the makeup of the new Cabinet answering to Putin and Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev, with three-fourths of the members having been replaced.
9.
Superjet Missing in Indonesia With 50 on Board
A dark cloud was cast Wednesday on the revival of Russia’s aviation industry when a Sukhoi-built Superjet 100 with 50 people on board disappeared from the radar screens of Indonesian flight controllers.
10.
Why Putin's Days Are Numbered
On Monday, Vladimir Putin will take the presidential oath of office for the third time. After 12 years in power, Putin has increased his control over the country's major institutions, the siloviki and state bureaucracy.


