


	Remember me on this computer
	Forgot your password?
	Register

MT news

Exhibition "Children and the City", The Moscow Times at Art Moskva

In the framework of the international art fair ART Moskva, which is being held from the 14th to the 18th of May 2008 at the Central House of Artists on Krimsky Val, The Moscow Times presents an exhibition of works by the newspaper's photo correspondents, Igor Tabokov and Vladimir Filonov. The exhibition is organized with the support of ZAO Unified Financial Group INVEST, which is a part of the group of companies UFG Asset Management (UFG
AM). Since its foundation, the company has actively supported credible
social projects.

Testimonials

"For me, The Moscow Times is not only a leading, objective, independent and informative publication, but it is also a reliable partner in carrying out business conferences on the most essential themes of the economic development of the country."

-Mikhail Tsarev, Managing Partner
KPMG Strategic Development in Russia and CIS

Market Matters : Oil Tax Pledge Buoys Markets
Markets surged after the swearing-in of Dmitry Medvedev as president in a pomp-filled ceremony Wednesday and a tax-cutting speech by Vladimir Putin the day after, when he was approved as prime minister.

Russia Investment Roadshow : Scenes From Last Year's Forum



Saturday, May 17, 2008 Updated at 16 May 2008 0:29 Moscow Time

The Moscow Times » Issue 3888 » Opinion

Avoiding Military Reforms

22 April 2008By Alexander GoltsThe word "military reform" sends terrible chills down the spines of military officers because it could mean that their alternative sources of income in the shadow economy will dry up or, even worse, that they will lose their jobs outright.

In an attempt to sugarcoat the military modernization campaign, Defense Minister Anatoly Serdyukov has recommended that the word "reform" not be used to describe the series of changes he has introduced. "We have no plans for drastic changes. We are just putting the affairs of the armed forces in order," he insisted.

To be sure, President Vladimir Putin has repeatedly stated that he is satisfied with the condition of the armed forces, and Serdyukov was not appointed to make revolutionary changes to the system.

It is essential that Serdyukov establish at least some kind of control over the billions of rubles that disappear without a trace in the Defense Ministry. But for some strange reason, his attempts to establish a modicum of financial accountability and transparency in the Defense Ministry have sparked a storm of protest from the military's top brass.

Serdyukov is planning to divest assets held by the military, to make army commanders answerable to their own financial officers and to strip military lawyers, doctors and journalists of their officer status. In reality, it is clear that any attempt by Serdyukov to introduce accountability, transparency and efficiency in the military a priori runs counter to the generals' fundamental view of how the armed forces should function on a daily basis.

Among other things, Serdyukov has proposed restructuring military entities into joint-stock companies and to auction off unused land. The military is one-fourth its size at the time of the collapse of the Soviet Union, but its vast holdings have not decreased proportionally. Serdyukov would like to reorganize the management of factories for repairing tanks, armored vehicles, aircraft and naval equipment, as well as restructuring farms owned by the Defense Ministry. These various structures are referred to as state unitary enterprises, and each belongs to its respective branch of the military -- the Army, Air Force or Navy. These enterprises are structured in such a way that any factory or farm director who cultivates the "right" relationship with central command can siphon off as much money as he wants from the enterprise he oversees. Of course, even Serdyukov's restructuring plan won't guarantee an end to corruption in the military, but the current system is particularly open to graft. Converting these enterprises to joint-stock companies -- complete with boards of directors and relatively transparent accounting practices -- at the very least will decrease the opportunities available for skimming off budgetary funds.

Serdyukov's initiative to strip the military's journalists, lawyers and doctors of officer rank is a clear attempt to decrease the number of officers. The army now has 400,000 officers out of a total 1.2 million service personnel. That comes out to one officer for every two soldiers. In most countries, officers constitute not more than 16 percent of a military's total personnel. In Russia, the bloated number of officers resembles an inverted pyramid, with nearly as many colonels as lieutenants.

But the generals argue that a large number of officers is necessary to maintain a mass-mobilization army -- one that could call up millions of reservists to fight a war against NATO. In answer to the charge that the number of colonels has nearly outstripped the number of lieutenants, the generals counter that someone must be available to lead the divisions of reservists.

Regarding the military's enormous property holdings, generals argue that, while these assets might be superfluous in peacetime, they will be essential in the event of a major conflict with NATO. In defending their mass-mobilization strategy, which is still stuck in an old Soviet mindset, the generals complain about the incompetence and ignorance of civilians running the Defense Department.

This is why attempts by Serdyukov and his advisers to put financial and accounting controls on military spending have led to a serious conflict with the entrenched military establishment. In the end, this will probably mean that the military brass will succeed in fending off the implementation of fundamental reforms, and Serdyukov's attempts to modernize the armed forces will largely be a fruitless exercise.

Alexander Golts is deputy editor of the online newspaper Yezhednevny Zhurnal.